Sunday 21st May - When Consultants Stop Making Sense

published12 days ago
1 min read

I've been following a recent twitter spat between Dave Snowden (Cynefin) and ​Niels Plaeging (BetaCodex) with a rising sense of alarm and disappointment. They are both experts in the field of complexity science which chiefly occupies itself with trying to explain why in business, management is so hard and why things always go wrong - or at least don't go as well as planned.

Complexity science is increasingly popular in management theory especially around IT and software projects. In a similar way that Systems Thinking is something of a management philosophy, neither of these ideas really tell you what to do next - only that things are complex and connected and it's tough.

Can you really map complexity and make meaningful judgements? And this, I believe, is the core of the argument. The whole affair feels a bit absurd and childish to the point they are blocking each other on twitter and then popping up again from different accounts. It sounds to me like a Douglas Adams plot point - complexity scientists falling out. How would he describe this? Rather than attempt to write it myself, I asked ChatGPT how DNA might describe it. I won't reproduce the whole text, but it did a good job on the whole and summarised it like this:

Like a tangled knot in the fabric of existence, the futility of this professional argument served as a reminder that even the most brilliant minds can sometimes get lost in the labyrinth of their own ideas. Perhaps, in the grand scheme of things, the pointlessness of this debate was a gentle nudge from the universe, urging us to embrace the beautiful chaos of existence, for it is in that chaos that true meaning lies.

I'm not sure Douglas Adams would have said something so direct, but I like the summary. Trust your experts, but don't let your experts get carried away with themselves.

Enjoy your Sunday.

-- Richard

How to Avoid the Organisational Big Ball of Mud

Published on May 17, 2023

You’ve started working on a new project. Your job is to lead your team through the challenges that you find. You must improve the reliability, speed and quality of software delivery. The project comes with a lot of pressure to deliver a system on a quick turnaround to interface and work with a client’s system.… Read More »How to Avoid the Organisational Big Ball of Mud


Software Delivery Club

Join my weekly newsletter to get the inside line on predictable, secure and reliable software and IT delivery. This is not a technology newsletter - this is a consequence-of-technology and the choices-we-make kind of newsletter. I talk about technology from the angle of software development practice, IT and operations, DevOps and organisational and business agility.

Read more from Software Delivery Club